New Bethel Ordinary Service List

Main Menu

• Appetizers

  • Breadsticks

    Nacho Cheese, Pizza Sauce, Garlic Butter

    Half	$3.99
    Full	$5.99

  • Potato Skins

    Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, Sour Cream

    $10.99

  • Chicken Strips

    Hand Breaded or Grilled, Choice of Sauce

    $8.99

  • Quesadilla

    Traditional, BBQ, Buffalo Pico, Jalapeno, Lettuce, Salsa

    $7.99

  • Fried Ravioli

    Marinara

    $10.99

  • Cheesy Garlic Bread

    Garlic Toast, Mozzarella, Pizza Sauce

    Half	$4.99
    Full	$6.99

  • Loaded Fries

    Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, Sour Cream

    $10.99

  • Fried Cauliflower

    Ranch

    $6.99

  • Beer Battered Onion Rings

    Petal Dipping Sauce

    Half	$5.99
    Full	$7.99

  • New Bethel Nachos

    Tortilla Chips, White Queso, BBQ Sauce, Pico, Guacamole, Sour Cream

    $9.99

  • Tenderloin Strips

    Hand-Breaded or Grilled, Horseradish Sauce, Ranch

    $8.99

  • Breaded Mushrooms

    Ranch

    $6.99

  • Mozzarella Sticks

    Marinara

    $6.99

• Wings

  Sauces: Mild | Buffalo | Hot | BBQ | Golden BBQ | Teriyaki | Firecracker | Mango Habanero. Rubs: Jamaican Jerk | Bonfire | #9 Lemon Pepper | BBQ | Cajun | Garlic. Signature Sauces: Bourbon Cola | Chipotle | Garlic Parmesan | Ghost Pepper | Jamaican Jerk BBQ | Maple Sriracha $1 Upcharge. Side of Sauce or Dressing: Small $0.50 | Large $1. Extra Celery $0.50

  • Traditional Bone in Wings

    10 Wings Served With Ranch or Blue Cheese And Celery

    $10.99

  • Boneless Wings

    10 Wings Served With Ranch or Blue Cheese And Celery

    1/2 Lb.	$7.49
    Full Lb.	$13.99

• Soups & Salads

  Dressings: Ranch | Bleu Cheese | French | Italian | Oil & Vinegar | 1000 Island | Honey Mustard | Balsamic Vinaigrette

  • Side Salad

    House or Caesar

    $4.99

  • Chicken Salad

    Hand Breaded or Grilled, Cheddar, Bacon, Tomato, Croutons

    $10.99

  • Chef Salad

    Ham, Turkey, Egg, Bacon, Cheddar, Tomato, Croutons

    $10.99

  • Wedge Salad

    Iceberg Wedge, Bacon, Bleu Cheese Crumbles, Red Onion, Tomato, Bleu Cheese Dressing

    $7.99

  • Chicken Caesar Salad

    Grilled Chicken, Parmesan, Croutons

    $10.99

  • Ham & Bean Soup

    Cup	$2.50
    Bowl	$4.99

  • Chili

    Cup	$2.50
    Bowl	$4.99

• Pizza

  The Signature Item of the Ordinary. Our Pizzas Are Made To Order Using Only the Freshest, Top Quality Meats, Veggies, And Cheese. Piled High And Baked In Our Traditional Brick Deck Pizza Ovens. Toppings - Veggies (For 10-inch $1 | For 12-inch $1.25 | For 16-inch $1.50): Mushroom | Black Olive | Green Pepper | Onion | Banana Pepper | Jalapeno | Tomato | Pineapple. Meats (For 10-inch $1.75 | For 12-inch $2 | For 16-inch $2.25): Pepperoni | Sausage | Ham | Bacon | Italian Sausage | Grilled Chicken | Ground Beef | Crumbled Sausage. Extra Cheese: For 10-inch $1.50 | For 12-inch $2 | For 16-inch $2.50. Gluten Free Crust (10- and 12-inch) acid $2. Take & Bake: Any Of Our Famous Pizzas Can Be Prepared For You To Take Home And Bake Yourself

  • Deluxe

    Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Mushroom, Black Olives, Green Pepper, Onion

    10 Inch	$16.99
    12 Inch	$19.99
    16 Inch	$25.99

  • BBQ Chicken

    Grilled Chicken, Red Onion, BBQ Sauce

    10 Inch	$14.99
    12 Inch	$16.99
    16 Inch	$20.99

  • Meat Lovers

    Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Italian Sausage, Bacon

    10 Inch	$16.99
    12 Inch	$19.99
    16 Inch	$25.99

  • Cheese Pizza

    Build Your Own

    10 Inch	$12.99
    12 Inch	$13.99
    16 Inch	$17.99

  • Hawaiian

    Ham, Pineapple, BBQ Sauce

    10 Inch	$14.99
    12 Inch	$16.99
    16 Inch	$20.99

• Burgers

  Fresh, 1/2 Pound, 100% Angus Beef. Toppings: Lettuce | Tomato | Pickle | Onion | Mayo. Served On a Brioche Bun With Choice Of Side Item. Substitute Onion Rings or House or Caesar Salad For $2

  • Texas BBQ Burger

    Cheddar, Bacon, BBQ Sauce, Onion Ring

    $10.99

  • Bacon Bleu Burger

    Bacon, Bleu Cheese Crumbles

    $10.99

  • Patty Melt

    Marble Rye, Sautéed Onions, Swiss, 1000 Island

    $10.99

  • Shroom Burger

    Sautéed Mushrooms, Swiss

    $10.99

  • Build Your Own Burger

    Cheeses: American | Swiss | Cheddar | Pepper Jack. Toppings: Banana Pepper | Jalapeno | Grilled Onions | Grilled Mushrooms | Pico. Premium Toppings: Bacon | Bleu Cheese Crumbles | Onion Ring | Guacamole

    $8.99

• Tacos

  All Served On Flour Tortilla

  • Spicy Chicken

    Hand Breaded or Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Pico, Chipotle Sauce, Bonfire Rub

    $8.99

  • Bourbon Cola Brisket

    House Smoked Brisket, Shredded Pepper Jack Pickled Red Onion, Bourbon Cola Sauce

    $9.99

  • BBQ Pulled Pork

    House Smoked Pork, BBQ Rub, Cheese, Pico, BBQ Sauce

    $8.99

  • Boom Boom Shrimp

    Breaded Popcorn Shrimp, Lettuce, Pico, Boom Boom Sauce

    $9.99

  • Beef Tacodilla

    Shredded Beef, Cheese, Pico, Guacamole, Sour Cream, Grilled Tortilla

    $9.99

• Sandwiches

  • Tenderloin

    Pork Loin, Hand Breaded or Grilled

    $9.99

  • Texas Toast BLT

    Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, Texas Toast

    $9.99

  • Fish Sandwich

    Hand-Breaded Haddock

    $9.99

  • Chicken Sandwich

    Hand Breaded or Grilled

    $10.99

  • Beef Brisket Sandwich

    House-Smoked Brisket. Side of BBQ Sauce

    $12.99

  • Pulled Pork Sandwich

    House-Smoked Pork, Side of BBQ Sauce

    $11.99

  • Chicken Wrap

    Hand Breaded or Grilled, Pico, Lettuce, Cheese, Chipotle Sauce

    $10.99

  • Grilled Ham & Cheese

    Smoked Pit Ham. Choice of Cheese And Bread

    $9.99

  • Cuban Sandwich

    Ham, Pulled Pork, Mustard, Pickle, Hoagie Bun

    $13.99

• Sides

  • Fries

    $2.79

  • Potato Salad

    $2.79

  • Cottage Cheese

    $2.79

  • Green Beans

    $2.79

  • Cole Slaw

    $2.79

  • Apple Sauce

    $2.79

• Desserts

  • Bread Pudding

    Cinnamon Sauce

    $4.99

  • Brownie ala Mode

    Brownie, Vanilla Ice Cream, Whipped Cream, Chocolate Syrup

    $5.99

• Kids Menu

  12 & Under. Includes: Soft Drink, Apple Juice or Milk

  • Chicken Fingers

    With fries

    $5.99

  • 7-inch Cheese Pizza

    $5.99

  • Mini Corn Dogs

    With fries

    $5.99

  • Grilled Cheese

    With fries

    $5.99

• Beverages

  • Pepsi Products

    $2.99

  • O.J.

    16oz

    $2.99

  • Milk

    16oz

    $2.99

  • Coffee

    $1.99

  • Iced Tea

    $2.99

Drink Menu

• Craft Beers

  • Ace Perry Hard Cider - Sebastopol, CA - 5.0% ABV

  • Bare Hands Westy IPA - Granger Indiana - 7.0% ABV

  • Bare Hands Rotating - Granger, IN

  • Bell's Two Hearted American WA - Comstock, MI - 7.0% ABV

  • Bloomington Brewing Kirkwood Cream Ale - Bloomington, IN - 5.0% ABV

  • Breckenridge Nitro Vanilla Porter - Breckenridge, CO - 4.7% ABV

  • Daredevil Liftoff IPA - Anderson, IN - 7.2% ABV

  • Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA - Milton, DE - 6.0% ABV

  • Elysian Space Dust IPA - Seattle, WA - 8.2% ABV

  • Founders Brewing Rotating - Grand Rapids, MI

  • Goose Island 312 Wheat - Chicago, IL - 4.2% ABV

  • Greenbush Star Chicken Shotgun IPA - Sawyer, MI - 6.8% ABV

  • Kentucky Bourbon Barrel Ale - Lexington, KY - 8.2% ABV

  • Kentucky Vanilla Barrel Ale - Lexington, KY - 5.5% ABV

  • Lagunitas IPA - Petaluma, Ca - 6.2% ABV

  • Natural Liberty American Pale Ale - Indianapolis, IN - 5.4% ABV

  • New Belgium Fat Tire - Fort Collins, CO - 5.3% ABV

  • New Holland Dragons Milk Porter - Holland, MI - 11.0% ABV

  • Sun King Cream Ale - Indianapolis, IN - 5.3% ABV

  • Sun King Osiris Pale Ale - Indianapolis, IN - 5.6% ABV

  • Sun King Wee Mac Scottish Ale - Indianapolis, IN - 5.3% ABV

  • Taxman Deduction Belgian Dubbel - Bargersville, IN - 8.0% ABV

  • Taxman Exemption Belgian Trippel - Bargersville, IN - 8.5% ABV

  • Three Floyd's Rotating - Munster, IN

  • Quaff On Six Foot Blonde - Nashville, IN - 4.0% ABV

  • 450 North Brewing Rotating - Columbus, IN

• Domestics

  • Blue Moon

  • Michelob Amber Boch

  • Bud Light

  • Michelob Ultra

  • Bud Light Lime

  • Natural Light

  • Bud Select

  • Pabst Blue Ribbon

  • Budweiser

  • Red's Apple Ale

  • Coors Banquet

  • Rolling Rock

  • Coors Light

  • Sam Adams

  • MGD

  • Smirnoff Ice

  • Miller Lite

  • Yuengling

  • Miller High Life

  • Yuengling Light

  • Miller 64

• Imports

  • Corona

  • Corona Light

  • Dos Equis

  • Guinness

  • Heineken

  • Modelo Especial

  • New Castle

  • Stella Artois

• Sutter Home

  • Cabernet

  • Chardonnay

  • Merlot

  • Moscato

  • Pinot Grigio

  • White Zinfandel

• Drink Specials

  • Monday - Domestics

    $2.00

  • Tuesday - Jim Beam & Captain Morgan

    $4.00

  • Wednesday - $1 Off All Imports

  • Thursday - $1 Off All Craft Beer

  • Friday - Tito's & Maker's Mark

    $5.00

  • Saturday - Long Islands & Vegas Bombs

    $4.00

  • Sunday - Bloody Mary's

    $4.00